Comparative Civil Procedure
Procedure & Regularity for Accuracy, True Dispute Resolution and Happiness

Four Issues of Civil Procedure in a Claim for Service Charges by a Coastal Village: A Critique of Judgment No. 9509970909100166, dated 22 June 2016, of Branch Three of the Supreme Court of Iran

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Pouya Saebkia

PhD Candidate inPrivate Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran

Abstract
Supreme Court of Iran, Branch Three, Judgment No. 9509970909100166, dated July 1, 2016, concerning a claim for service charges and ordinary expenses of a coastal community, raises four procedural issues. First, where a “tourist village” is named as plaintiff, establishing the managers’ authority to sue requires establishing the owners’ collective will in their appointment. Collective decision-making may be based on law or contract. In co-ownership, the law grants the owners’ assembly authority to decide by majority and determines the person entitled to sue; under contractual management, the managers’ authority to sue requires the consent of all owners. The principal entitled to sue must be identified. Second, including a late-payment penalty in the expert calculation, when it was not claimed in the statement of claim, is impermissible because it changes the claim. Third, excluding debts relating to service charges and ordinary expenses from Article 522, because the debt was not crystallized, is justifiable. Fourth, where an investigative deficiency and substantive objection coexist, referring the case back to the court that rendered the quashed judgment is defensible to prevent inconsistency in the new judgment. The study concludes that the judgment could have explained the principal’s identification and rejection of compensation for delay.

Keywords

Service Charge Claim
Standing to Bring an Action
Damages for Delay in Payment
Subjects
Comparative Civil Procedure
Volume 2, Special Number
Commemorative Volume Honoring His Excellency The Judge Hassan Ghaffarpour Maraghi President of 3rd Branch of the Supreme Court, Iran
2026

  • Receive Date 02 October 2026
  • Accept Date 03 October 2026
  • Publish Date 23 October 2026

Home

Guide for Authors

Submit Manuscript

Reviewers

Contact Us